Different physical and mental morbidities such as pain, fatigue, depressed mood andcognitive impairment can be triggered by coronavirus infection. Transcranial directcurrent stimulation (tDCS), an easy-to-apply, non-pharmacological and safe technique, hasbeen used to attenuate these symptoms caused by other diseases, and, therefore, it isexpected that it can also attenuate them when generated by COVID-19. It is known that thepersistent inflammatory state observed after COVID-19 would be related to the progressionof these negative symptoms. As non-invasive brain stimulation can also attenuate acuteand persistent inflammation, it can be estimated that tDCS can be a useful tool torecover immune function and reduce post-COVID-19 morbidity.
The aim of this study is to investigate if Direct Current Electrical Stimulation (tDCS)
associated with motor and/or cognitive training is capable of reducing neuropsychiatric
symptoms, as well as immune changes induced in COVID-19.
Volunteers will be randomized and allocated into four groups (Fatigue; Pain; Cognitive
deficit and Depressed mood) and each group will be divided into two subgroups: 1) real
tDCS + motor or cognitive training; and, 2) sham tDCS + motor or cognitive training
according to each outcome. The volunteers will be evaluated in two aspect:
immunometabolic evaluation (i) and clinical assessment (ii). The measures will pe
performed in three moments: baseline (session 1); 72 hours after the last intervention
(session 12) and follow up - 15 days after the last intervention (session 13).
(i) The immunometabolic evaluation will start with the participant's blood collection,
after fasting for 8-12 hours, without having practiced intense physical activity and
without drinking alcohol in the 24 hours prior to the collect. The blood will be
allocated in 10 vacutainer tubes of 5ml containing EDTA for plasma separation, in 2 dry
vacutainer tubes of 5ml for serum separation and 1 vacutainer tube of 5ml containing
fluoride. In particular, 1 dry tube must rest for 1h, for subsequent BDNF analysis. 2
serum tubes, 2 plasma tubes and 1 fluoride tube should be centrifuged at 3,500 rpm for 15
minutes at 4°C, and the samples should be stored at -80°C for later analysis and the
other fresh plasma tubes used (up to 2 hours after collection) for whole blood and PBMC
stimuli.
Stimulation of whole blood with LPS, culture of peripheral blood mononuclear cells
(PBMC), assessment of oxidative stress, assessment of adenine and LPS purine levels in
plasma, analysis of immunophenotyping and apoptosis by flow cytometry, assessment of
expression of purinoreceptors, mitochondrial assays in monocytes and T lymphocytes,
evaluation of the generation of reactive oxygen species and quantification of several
mediators by ELISA.
(ii) The clinical assessment will be performed using the following outcome measures:
COVID clinical situation - IInitially, modules 1 and 2 of the Case Report Form - CRF
(Pcovid frameost COVID-19 CRF) of the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) will be
completed. Where module 1 comprises demographic data and clinical information related to
the acute episode of COVID-19 and module 2 includes questions related to vaccination,
occupational and functional status of the volunteer.
Fatigue - The Modified Impact of Fatigue Scale (MFIS) contains 21 items that analyze
cognitive, physical and psychosocial issues in relation to fatigue, assessing the impact
that is caused in the patient's life.
Pain - Brief Pain Inventory (BPI) assesses pain severity, impact of pain on daily
function, pain location, pain medications, and amount of pain relief in the last 24 hours
and last week; Visual Analog Scale (VAS) consists of a ruler numbered from 0 to 10 and
divided into three parts, light, moderate and severe, with visual aid to facilitate the
measurement of the patient's pain intensity.
Cognitive deficit - Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) instrument that quickly
identifies cognitive declines in patients; FAS Test is a Verbal Fluency Test -
Phonological Fluency Test that assesses verbal learning and the ability to produce words
verbally; Random Number Generator (RNG test) assesses language and executive function;
Digit span that will be used to assess the ability to focus, maintain attention, and
mental manipulation. In the follow up, the CFL-test will be added to a verbal fluency
test.
Depressed mood - Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) measures symptoms of
anxiety and depression and consists of 14 items, seven for the anxiety subscale
(HADS-Anxiety) and seven for the depression subscale (HADS-Depression); Brunel Mood Scale
(BRUMS) used to quickly measure the patient's mood state.
Level of physical activity - The short version of IPAQ will be performed to identify if
the volunteer has a life with active physical activities. It makes it possible to
estimate the weekly time used for physical activities.
Vital signs - at the end of the scales, the signs of each patient will be measured: blood
pressure, heart rate, respiratory rate and peripheral O2 saturation, parameters used to
verify the hemodynamic status of the volunteer.
State of strength and effort - the handgrip strength test and perception of effort
performed with the dynamometer will be used, quantitatively indicating the muscle
strength of the hand and forearm.
Exercise capacity - the functional capacity and aerobic resistance of the participant
will be evaluated through the 6-minute walk test. The test measures the distance that the
volunteer covers in a period of 6 minutes walking at a stable speed.
At the end, a questionnaire of adverse effects of the evaluation will be carried out,
containing information regarding any discomfort felt during the evaluation.
The intervention process will be carried out with Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation
which will be applied for 30 minutes (2 mA; 0.057 mA/cm²) during motor or cognitive
training. For symptoms of pain and/or fatigue, the anode will be positioned in the area
referring to the left primary motor cortex (C3, according to the EEG positioning system).
For symptoms of depressed mood and/or cognitive impairment, the anode will be positioned
in the area of the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (F3). In both situations, the
cathode will be positioned in the contralateral supraorbital region. In sham tDCS, the
same parameters and setup as the real stimulation will be used, however, the application
time will be 30 seconds, but the electrodes will be maintained for 30 minutes.
In motor training, the treadmill training protocol will last a total of 30 minutes and
will be carried out during the application of tDCS. After positioning the tDCS
electrodes, a cardiac monitor will be positioned on the individual to control HR. Before
starting the protocol on the treadmill, the values of the perceived exertion scale (Borg)
and HR should be noted.
Initially, the target HR for each part of the intervention will be determined. The
formula by Tanaka et al., (2001) will be used to determine the maximum HR, with maximum
HR = 208 - (0.7*age). For participants who use beta-blockers, the formula by Brawner et
al., (2004) will be used, with maximum HR = 164 - (0.7*age).
The initial five minutes will be a warm-up. To achieve this, the target HR must be
maintained at 50-60% of the maximum HR. The speed of the treadmill must be adjusted to
maintain the HR within the pre-established target range. At five minutes, the Borg scale
values, treadmill speed and HR must be noted. The central 20 minutes will be considered
as the main part. To achieve this, the target HR must be maintained at 64-76% of the
maximum HR. If the participant chooses to stop the treadmill session, the treadmill must
be turned off and the participant must remain seated until the end of the tDCS
application.
For cognitive training, carried out during tDCS, an n-Back task will be performed online
in PsyToolkit (https://www.psytoolkit.org/). For a benefit on working memory learning
curves. Performed for the outcomes of cognitive impairment and depressed mood. During the
test, the volunteer will have to indicate which letter was projected by the application
two letters ago. The system will show one letter followed by another, the volunteer must
press the "space" key on the computer keyboard when the letter that was shown in the two
positions above reappears.
The study will be carried out simultaneously in two research centers in Brazil:
Laboratory of Applied Neuroscience (LANA), Federal University of Pernambuco (UFPE),
Pernambuco, Brazil and at the Department of Physical Education, Faculty of Science and
Technology - Campus Presidente Prudente (FCT/UNESP), São Paulo, Brazil.
Device: Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS)
tDCS deliver low-intensity electrical currents (2 mA) through electrodes placed on the
scalp. It is used to influence brain function, modulating the neuronal activity in
specific areas, in a non-invasive way, as the stimulation may not be perceived
sensorially due to the low intensity. In some cases, it can provide mild tingling and
bring minimal discomfort. It has the ability to increase or decrease the cortical
excitability of neurons, influencing the polarization of neuronal membranes, with the
anodal pole (positive) facilitating depolarization that results in increased neuronal
excitability in the area, and the cathodal pole (negative) promoting a hyperpolarization
of the neuronal resting membrane potential that reduces cortical excitability, used to
inhibit activity in a particular cortical area.
Other Name: non-invasive brain stimulation, neuroConn (Germany)
Behavioral: Motor Training
Motor training will be performed on the treadmill with the speed respecting the limits of
the patient's maximum heart rate. To determine the maximum heart rate, the calculation
must be performed: maximum heart rate = 208 - (0.7*age). For participants who use
beta-blockers, the following formula will be used: maximum heart rate = 164 - (0.7*age).
Just for the arms of fatigue and pain.
Behavioral: Cognitive Training
an n-Back task will be performed online at PsyToolkit (https://www.psytoolkit.org/). Just
for the arms of cognitive impairment and depressed mood.
Inclusion Criteria:
- Long COVID-19 (>3 months)
- The presence of at least one of the following symptoms, after diagnosed SARS-COV-2
infection:
Persistent pain Fatigue Depressed mood Cognitive impairment
Exclusion Criteria:
- Hemodynamic instability
- Historic of use or abuse of drugs or alcohol
- Use of medications that may interfere with the study results (anti-inflammatories
and antibiotics)
- Metallic implant in skull and face
- Implant in the central nervous system
- Pacemaker
Applied Neuroscience Laboratory-LANA
Recife, Pernambuco, Brazil
Department of Physical Education, Faculty of Science and Technology
Presidente Prudente, São Paulo, Brazil
Kátia Monte-Silva, PhD
+55 81 988631322
monte.silvakk@gmail.com
Patrícia Lopes, graduation
+55 81 999897661
patricia.flima@ufpe.br