Respiratory tract infections (RTIs) are prevalence community diseases and is the thirdleading cause of death worldwide. Rapid diagnosis of RTIs is essential as it drivesdecision points such as treatment, disposition, and containment. According to recent CDC(The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) updates, nasopharyngeal swabbing is thepreferred method of specimen collection for most RTIs such as SARS-COV-2. This process isinvasive and traumatizing for patients as it requires probing (20 seconds) of theposterior nasopharynx with swab applicator. In some cases, this procedure has resulted inpain and injury. Because of the invasive nature of the procedure, patients often refusetesting or withdraw during the collection process resulting in inadequate specimenprocurement. The study principle investigators (PI) have developed 2 novel specimencollection devices: 1) nasopharyngeal wash collection device (NP wash device) and 2)saliva collection device (the Oral Capsule). Both devices are designed for ease of useeither by a healthcare professional or a patient. The benefits of such collection devicesinclude 1) minimizing the invasive nature of the procedure because a swab applicator isnot utilized and 2) minimizing infection risk to healthcare professional because thestudy devices can be self-administered when applicable. The study will enroll 1000participants from a pool of patients presenting to the Nebraska Medicine EmergencyDepartment (ED) who received a nasopharyngeal (NP) swab viral PCR test as part of theirED work up. Enrolled patients will be asked to provide four total specimens: 1) a salivadrool specimen, 2) a saliva Oral Capsule specimen, 3) a NP wash specimen, and 4) a fingerstick serum specimen. Patients are able to opt out of any specimen collection method.Study specimens 1, 2, 3 will undergo a respiratory pathogen panel (RPP) PCR test andCOVID-19 antibody testing. Study specimen 4 will undergo COVID-19 antibody testing andwill function as a serum control for antibody detection.
Respiratory tract infections (RTIs) are high prevalence community diseases and is the
third leading cause of death worldwide. It is estimated that a new infectious disease
emerges at a rate of one per year, making early disease detection critically important.
Within the past few decades, we have seen an increase in cases of novel respiratory
illnesses such as SARS (severe acute respiratory syndrome), H1N1 (Swine Influenza), MERS
(Middle East respiratory syndrome), and SARS-COV-2 (severe acute respiratory syndrome
coronavirus 2). Rapid diagnosis of RTIs is essential to the management of patients
experiencing respiratory symptoms as it drives decision points such as treatment and
disposition. There are currently millions of confirmed SARS-COV-2 cases globally. This
number is likely underreported given the limitations and barriers to confirmatory
testing. This problem is compounded by other RTIs such as influenza and rhinovirus, which
are also tested via a nasopharyngeal swab specimen. According to recent updates from the
CDC, nasopharyngeal swabbing is the preferred method of specimen collection for
SARS-COV-2. The nasopharyngeal swab method is also commonly used in the testing of other
viral pathogens such as influenza, respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), rhinovirus, and
human parainfluenza. This process can be somewhat invasive and traumatizing for patients
as it requires probing (10-20 seconds) of the posterior nasopharynx with a stiff swab
applicator. In some cases, this procedure has been known to result in pain and injury.
Because of the invasive nature of the procedure, patients often refuse testing or
withdraw during the collection process resulting in inadequate specimen procurement. In
our effort to streamline the specimen collection process, our team has developed working
prototypes of two specimen devices (a NP wash collection device and an Oral Capsule
saliva collection device).
- The NP wash device is designed to irrigate the patient's nasopharyngeal passage with
3 ml of sterile saline and recollect the solution for testing. In our preliminary
testing, the study device was successful in collecting RNase P from the nasal
passages 100% of the time while achieving a mean Cycle Threshold (CT) value of 29.5.
Participants in early studies also reported the study device to be more comfortable
(0.3/10 pain) than the nasopharyngeal swab (8/10 pain).
- The Oral Capsule device is a soft-hollow device that is inserted into the mouth,
overlying their molars. As the patient bites on the device, it generates an
intermittent suction force which pulls saliva into the device's specimen chamber. In
preliminary testing, the saliva collection device was successful in consistently
collecting approximately 1 ml of saliva with 5-10 seconds of use.
The study design of this new protocol will allow the study investigators calculate the
study devices' sensitivity and specificity for pathogen testing and test for antibody
response from each respective specimen, along with improving enrollment rates. This study
will enroll up to 1000 participants from a pool of ED patients who received a
nasopharyngeal swab for PCR testing as part of their standard work up. Enrolled patients
will provide four specimens 1) saliva drool specimen, 2) Oral Capsule saliva specimen, 3)
NP wash specimen, and 4) finger stick serum specimen. Specimens 1, 2, 3 will undergo RPP
PCR testing and COVID-19 antibody testing. Specimen 4 will undergo COVID-19 antibody
testing. Patients can opt out of any of the four study specimen collection processes.
Manufacturing of the NP Wash and the Oral Capsule devices is handled by the UNMC
Department of Emergency Medicine fabrication lab. The NP wash study device is
manufactured using fused deposition modeling (FDM) 3D printing technology with polylactic
acid (PLA) printing material. The Oral Capsule device is manufactured using FDM 3D
printing technology with polypropylene printing material. All study device will be
sterilized via a cidex rinse, allowed to dry, then stored in a specimen bag. The NP wash
device is designed to irrigate the user's nasopharyngeal cavity with 3 ml of sterile
saline and recapture the irrigation solution into a specimen chamber as it drains back
from their nose. The Oral Capsule device is designed to collect saliva via intermittent
suction force generated within the device as the patient repeatedly bite on the device.
With the implementation of our study devices we anticipate the following potential
paradigm shifts in testing procedures: 1) minimizing the invasive nature of the procedure
as a swab applicator is not utilized and 2) the procedure can be performed by a
healthcare professional or solely by the patient, minimizing the risk of cross-infection
to the healthcare professional. Nasopharyngeal irrigation is a common home remedy
(neti-pots/bottles) for cold symptoms and is generally well tolerated by the user.
Diagnostic Test: Respiratory pathogen panel PCR test
Respiratory pathogen panel PCR test and COVID-19 antibody test.
Diagnostic Test: COVID-19 antibody test
COVID-19 antibody test
Inclusion Criteria:
- Age 19 years or older presenting to the UNMC ED, or admitted from the UNMC ED with a
non-research nasopharyngeal swab ordered.
Exclusion Criteria:
- None, if the inclusion criterion is met.
Thanh Nguyen
Omaha, Nebraska, United States
Investigator: Thanh Nguyen, PhD
Contact: 402-559-7884
thang.nguyen@unmc.edu
Thanh Nguyen, PhD
402-559-7884
thang.nguyen@unmc.edu
Brooklin K Zimmerman, MSN
402-559-5237
brooklin.zimmerman@unmc.edu
Thanh Nguyen, PhD, Principal Investigator
University of Nebraska